Borehole vs. Public Water Supply: What’s better for Nigerian homes?

Water is essential for daily life, yet many Nigerian households struggle with securing a reliable and clean water supply.

With challenges such as inconsistent government supply, poor infrastructure, and increasing costs, homeowners are often left to decide between two main water sources: borehole water and public water supply.

This article explores the pros and cons of each option, helping Nigerian homeowners make an informed decision about their water needs.

Understanding the Two Water Sources

A. Borehole Water Supply

A borehole is a deep, narrow well drilled into the ground to access underground water. Boreholes are equipped with pumps to extract water for household use. In Nigeria, many residential and commercial properties rely on boreholes due to unreliable public water supply.

How Boreholes Work:

• A drilling company is hired to dig a borehole deep enough to reach an underground water source.
• A pumping system is installed to extract and distribute the water.
• Water is stored in overhead tanks and can be treated before use.

Cost of Borehole Installation:

• Drilling costs range from ₦500,000 to ₦3,000,000, depending on location and depth.
• Pump and plumbing system installation can add ₦100,000 to ₦500,000.
• Maintenance costs include periodic servicing and repairs.

B. Public Water Supply

Public water is provided by government agencies such as the Water Board. It is distributed through a network of pipelines to homes connected to the system.

How Public Water Works:

• Water is sourced from rivers, dams, or reservoirs.
• It undergoes treatment at government plants before distribution.
• Homes connected to the network receive water through pipes and pay monthly tariffs.

Cost of Public Water Supply:

• Connection fees vary from ₦50,000 to ₦200,000, depending on location.
• Monthly bills range from ₦1,000 to ₦5,000, depending on consumption.
• No personal maintenance required.

Read This: Nail vs. screws: Which is Better for Different parts of a house?

2. Pros and Cons of Borehole Water

Pros:

✅ Independence from Government Supply – You have control over your water source and do not rely on external providers.
✅ 24/7 Availability – As long as the borehole is functional, water is always accessible.
✅ Long-Term Cost Savings – Despite high initial costs, boreholes eliminate monthly water bills.
✅ Can Be Treated for Better Quality – Homeowners can install filters and purifiers to enhance water safety.

Cons:

❌ High Initial Cost – The drilling and setup process is expensive.
❌ Risk of Contamination – Poorly managed boreholes can be contaminated by nearby sewage or industrial waste.
❌ Maintenance Required – Pumps and pipes require periodic servicing to ensure efficiency.

3. Pros and Cons of Public Water Supply

Pros:

✅ Lower Upfront Costs – Homeowners only need to pay a connection fee, making it an affordable option.
✅ Government Quality Control – Water is treated at public facilities before reaching homes.
✅ No Personal Maintenance – The government is responsible for repairs and maintenance of the system.

Cons:

❌ Inconsistent Supply – Many areas in Nigeria experience frequent water shortages.
❌ Quality Concerns – Aging infrastructure and poor maintenance can lead to dirty or contaminated water.
❌ Ongoing Costs – Monthly water bills accumulate over time, potentially making it expensive in the long run.

4. Factors to Consider When Choosing

Choosing between a borehole and public water supply depends on several factors:

Availability

• If public water supply in your area is unreliable, a borehole might be the best option.
• If your home is in a location with a good public water network, it may be a more convenient choice.

Cost

• Can you afford the initial investment of a borehole?
• Are you comfortable paying monthly water bills for public water?

Water Quality

• Borehole water may require filtration or treatment to remove impurities.
• Public water may contain chemicals from treatment processes or contaminants from old pipes.

Long-Term Sustainability

• Boreholes offer long-term independence but require maintenance.
• Public water supply eliminates the need for maintenance but may not always be available when needed.

Read This: How the Right Nails Can Improve Home Durability in Nigeria

Which Is Better?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer; the best choice depends on individual household needs.

• If you prioritize reliability and long-term savings, a borehole is a better investment.
• If you prefer lower upfront costs and minimal maintenance, public water may be the right choice.

For many Nigerian homeowners, a hybrid approach, using a borehole as a primary source and public water as a backup, can provide the best balance of cost, convenience, and reliability.

Regardless of your choice, ensuring clean and safe water through proper treatment methods is essential for a healthy home.